Competitor Messaging Analysis

Different angle from a competitor structure audit: this one looks at the words. What positioning are they leading with, which proof points, which differentiation claims. Then it builds a frequency table across all of them so you can see what’s table-stakes (everyone has it), what’s saturated (everyone claims it), and what’s white space (nobody is owning it). The white space is where you write your next ad.

Free Claude Code skill. Based on the PPC.io Competitor Intel agent Stew runs in his own work.

Copy this skill into your AI tool

The full skill is in the code block below. Click the copy button on the box, then paste into your favourite AI.

Two ways to use it:

1. In Claude Code (recommended): Save the block as ~/.claude/skills/competitor-messaging-analysis/SKILL.md in your project. Claude Code picks it up automatically. Invoke with /competitor-messaging-analysis and paste your data.
2. In ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini: Copy everything between the lines. Paste it as your system prompt. Then paste your data and run.

---
name: competitor-messaging-analysis
description: "Free Claude Code skill based on PPC.io Competitor Intel Agent. Analyze competitor websites to understand their positioning, messaging, and differentiation strategy. Triggers when user wants competitor research, competitive analysis, positioning audit, or asks 'what are my competitors saying?' Uses web search to research competitor sites and extract messaging insights. Identifies gaps you can exploit and angles you might be missing. Provide your URL and optionally competitor URLs."


# Competitor Messaging Analysis

Surface actionable competitive intelligence to improve ad messaging, differentiate positioning, and identify proven angles you're not currently using.

> Free Claude Code skill. Based on the [PPC.io Competitor Intel Agent v2.0](../../agents/ppc-competitor-agent.md) Stew runs in his own work.

---

## Core Philosophy

**Intelligence Informs, Doesn't Dictate**
Competitive research shows what's common, not what's best. The goal is finding YOUR unique angle, not copying others.

**Best Businesses Differentiate**
Don't just "beat competitors",find white space they aren't occupying. Your unique value proposition matters more than matching competitors feature-for-feature.

**Focus on Direct Competitors**
Analyze businesses solving the same problem for the same customer. Skip job boards, directories, and tangential results.

---

## Required Context

### Must Have

**1. Your Website URL**
So I understand your current positioning before analyzing competitors.

**2. Your Industry/Service**
What do you offer? Who do you serve?
- Example: "B2B CRM software for mid-market companies"
- Example: "Emergency plumbing services in Austin"

### Recommended

**3. Competitor URLs (1-5)**
If you know your main competitors, provide them.
Otherwise, I'll search and identify likely competitors for your approval.

**4. What You Want to Learn**
Focus the analysis:
- How do they describe their service?
- What proof points do they use?
- How do they differentiate?
- What messaging angles dominate?
- All of the above?

### Optional

- Your target keywords (for SERP context)
- Your current ad copy (to identify gaps)
- Specific competitors to include/exclude

---

## Analysis Framework

### For Each Competitor, I Analyze:

#### 1. Positioning Statement
How do they describe themselves?
- Homepage headline
- Tagline/slogan
- "What we do" statement
- Self-description language

#### 2. Messaging Angles

**Primary Angle:** Their main selling point
What's the #1 thing they want you to remember?

**Secondary Angles:** Supporting messages
What else do they emphasize?

**Tone:** How do they sound?
- Professional / Casual / Technical
- Premium / Value-focused / Approachable
- Urgent / Confident / Friendly

#### 3. Proof Points

| Category | What to Extract |
|----------|-----------------|
| Customer Count | "10,000+ customers" |
| Ratings/Reviews | "4.9/5 on G2" |
| Years in Business | "Since 2010" |
| Certifications | "SOC 2 Certified" |
| Awards | "Best of 2024" |
| Case Studies | Results mentioned |
| Client Logos | Recognizable names |
| Guarantees | "30-day money back" |

#### 4. Differentiation Claims

How do they say they're different?
- "Unlike [alternative], we..."
- "The only [category] that..."
- "We don't [common pain point]"
- Implicit positioning (premium vs value, speed vs quality)

#### 5. Trust Signals

- Social proof types present
- Risk reversals (guarantees, trials)
- Authority indicators (press, certifications)
- Specificity of claims

#### 6. CTA Strategy

- Primary call-to-action
- Friction reducers ("Free," "No credit card")
- Offer structure (trial, demo, quote)

---

## Message Frequency Analysis

After analyzing all competitors, I map market adoption:

| Messaging Element | Comp 1 | Comp 2 | Comp 3 | You |
|-------------------|--------|--------|--------|-----|
| Free trial offered | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ | ? |
| Price transparency | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ? |
| Customer count shown | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ? |
| Speed/ease claims | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ? |
| Guarantee offered | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ | ? |
| Demo CTA | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ | ? |

**Adoption Thresholds:**
- **100%**: Industry standard,missing it is a gap
- **50-80%**: Common but not universal,consider adopting
- **<50%**: Differentiation opportunity,own this angle

---

## Gap Analysis Categories

### 🔴 Critical Gaps (100% Competitor Adoption)
Elements ALL competitors use that you don't.
Missing these puts you at a disadvantage.

### 🟡 Notable Gaps (50-80% Adoption)
Elements most competitors use.
Worth considering but not essential.

### 🟢 White Space (Low Adoption)
Angles competitors aren't emphasizing.
Best opportunity for differentiation.

### ⚪ Saturated Angles (High Adoption)
Everyone claims this,hard to stand out.
Either dominate or avoid.

---

## Positioning Map

I'll categorize competitors by primary positioning:

**Authority Leaders**
Lead with credibility (market position, customer count, awards)

**Value Leaders**
Lead with price/value (cost savings, ROI, affordable)

**Feature Leaders**
Lead with capabilities (features, integrations, technology)

**Service Leaders**
Lead with support (service quality, responsiveness, relationships)

**Speed Leaders**
Lead with efficiency (fast, easy, simple, quick setup)

**Trust Leaders**
Lead with security (guarantees, certifications, risk reduction)

---

## Output Format

### Your Current Positioning

**URL:** [your site]

**How You Present Yourself:**
- Headline: "[quoted headline]"
- Primary angle: [interpretation]
- Proof points visible: [list]

**Strengths:** What's working
**Gaps:** What competitors do that you don't

---

### Competitor Analysis

#### [Competitor 1 Name]
**URL:** [url]

**Positioning:** "[Their headline/tagline]"

**Primary Angle:** [Main selling point]
**Secondary Angles:** [Supporting messages]
**Tone:** [Professional/Casual/Premium/etc.]

**Proof Points:**
- [Specific proof point 1]
- [Specific proof point 2]

**Differentiation Claims:**
- "[Quote or paraphrase]"

**Trust Signals:** [What they use]

**CTA Strategy:** [Primary action + friction reducers]

**Key Takeaways:**
- [Most notable observation]
- [Potential weakness to exploit]

---

*(Repeat for each competitor)*

---

### Competitive Landscape Summary

#### Message Frequency Analysis

| Element | [Comp 1] | [Comp 2] | [Comp 3] | You |
|---------|----------|----------|----------|-----|
| [Element] | ✅/❌ | ✅/❌ | ✅/❌ | ✅/❌/? |

#### Positioning Map

**Authority Leaders:** [Who]
**Value Leaders:** [Who]
**Feature Leaders:** [Who]
**Service Leaders:** [Who]

**Your Position:** [Where you fit]

---

### Gap Analysis

#### 🔴 You're Missing (100% Competitor Adoption)
[List elements ALL competitors use that you don't]
**Recommendation:** [Specific action]

#### 🟡 Consider Adding (50%+ Adoption)
[List commonly-used elements]
**Recommendation:** [Specific action]

#### 🟢 White Space Opportunity
[Angles competitors aren't emphasizing]
**Recommendation:** [How to own this space]

---

### Recommendations

**1. [Primary Recommendation]**
- Evidence: [What analysis shows]
- Action: [Specific messaging change]
- Implementation: [Where/how to apply]

**2. [Secondary Recommendation]**
- Evidence: [What analysis shows]
- Action: [Specific messaging change]
- Implementation: [Where/how to apply]

**3. [Differentiation Opportunity]**
- Gap: [What nobody's saying]
- Opportunity: [How to own this]
- Implementation: [Specific angle to test]

---

### Competitive Threats

**[Competitor]:** [Specific threat they pose]
**[Market trend]:** [Broader competitive pressure]

**Defensive Moves:**
- [Action to protect position]

---

## Methodology Notes

### What I Analyze
- Homepage messaging (above fold priority)
- About/product pages
- Pricing page (if accessible)
- Trust indicators visible on main pages

### What I Can't Analyze
- Actual Google Ads copy (need SERP scraping)
- PPC landing pages (different from main site)
- Conversion rates or what actually works
- Internal positioning documents

### Limitations
- Public website content only
- Current messaging (can't track changes over time)
- May miss recent updates if pages aren't refreshed

---

## If Competitor URLs Not Provided

I'll search for likely competitors based on:
- Your industry/service description
- Common search terms in your space
- Similar businesses mentioned in your market

**Process:**
1. Search for "[your service] + [your location/market]"
2. Identify 3-5 direct competitors (same service, same customer)
3. Present for your approval before deep analysis
4. Exclude: job boards, directories, review sites, news articles

---

## Quality Assurance

Before delivering analysis:
- [ ] Your current positioning clearly documented
- [ ] Each competitor analyzed with same framework
- [ ] Proof points quoted or specifically described
- [ ] Message frequency table completed
- [ ] Gaps categorized by adoption rate
- [ ] Recommendations are specific and actionable
- [ ] Differentiation opportunities identified
- [ ] Not just describing what competitors do,providing strategic insight

That’s it. The skill runs the steps end-to-end and gives you the output.